Trip edge or Full blade trip????

ChicagoSnow

Senior Member
Location
Chicago, IL.
All of my current plows that we use are of the "full trip" variety. Can anyone tell me the pro's and con's with trip edge plows.

Thank you,

ChicagoSnow
 

JD PLOWER

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
Somerville MA.
My only experience with trip blades is from a western 7.5 pro plow so I do have limited knowledge about these types of plows. The biggest advantage I've found between the two is the ability of the trip edge to keep the load moving especialy in heavy wet snow that is common on the east coast. The Fisher had much better rolling and stacking abilities than the western. I also noticed that the western absorbed the bumps (manholes, curbs) alot better than the Fisher did. However the western would fold flat to the ground when it was on something like rough asphalt or concrete or a change in grade was encountered. I do know that spring adjustments can help but it didn't help this particular plow. All that being said in these parts a company called curtis is becoming known as making a trip blade plow that is just as tough and effective as any trip edge.
 

cat320

2000 Club Member
Location
stoneham,ma
well I can tell you that the full trip blade is ok but i think that i would prefere the the fisher type trip blade.You trip it and it springs right back as the full trip at least the one that I had would trip and stay down untill i lifted it up off the ground.
 

slplow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
FRAMINGHAM, MA
Another thing that full trips do. Is when hitting an object ( man hole covers or packed snow) at full angle it tends to push the truck side way's. Where a trip edge will just go over it not pushing the truck side way's . I have used fisher ,western ,boss and meyers. I might try a diamond next.
 

snow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
Connecticut
Originally posted by JD PLOWER
All that being said in these parts a company called curtis is becoming known as making a trip blade plow that is just as tough and effective as any trip edge.

Curtis is now building a trip-edge plow and they also have an 8.5' v plow. I'll have some photos of the v plow tomorrow after i stop by my friends shop. The curtis mounting system is really easy to hookup, and the mount is barely noticable.


Bryan
 

Pelican

2000 Club Member
I ran moldboard trips (Meyers, Western) and then switched to Diamond with a trip edge and swore I'd never go back. As JD said, the trip edge won't fold over in wet snow, in fact it just keeps digging in. I used to get stuck quite a bit when the Meyers and Western would fold over and ride up on the snow, by the time I realized it was happening the truck was up on the snow too and I'd have to start digging.

The downside to the trip edge is ironically its tendency to keep digging. They work best on blacktop, don't try gravel or thawed bank run, your plow becomes a bulldozer. You also have to be more careful of obstacles, the trip edge is not as forgiving as the moldboard trip.

I've narrowed down my route to almost all blacktop, so the trip edge work great for me, the only time I get stuck now is if I slide off pavement on ice. I did go back to the moldboard trip with my new Blizzard, but it has 4 trip springs and so far the only thing that's tripped it is soft gravel. My new truck will have a poly trip edge, I'm interested to see how well this will work.
 

JD PLOWER

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
Somerville MA.
Bryan your as well informed as chuck :D.

I'm guessing that Curtis must have felt pressure to go to the trip edge from all the Fisher guys around here. Are they still going to use the trip blade? Also will the v be a trip blade? The only reason I know anything about these plows is that one of my subs runs an 8 footer and he loves it and I've seen more and more around here.
 

Rob

PlowSite.com Veteran
I have a Curtis. Previously had a Western Pro. With the shock and the 5 springs, I didn't have all that much trouble with it tripping while pushing, but when it did you had to stop and lift it to get it to straighten back up. The Curtis is very similar to the Western except there are "stops" so the moldboard can only go over about 30 degrees before it stops. Because of this, it will straighten back out and you don't have to worry about the moldboard going all the way flat and the truck riding up on top of it. I have used the Curtis for 3 seasons (though this last season shouldn't count) and have had no problems with it. The attachment is quick and simple, and the truck side mount is minimal so it it hardly noticable in the off-season. I would buy another one.
 

snow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
Connecticut
Originally posted by JD PLOWER
Bryan your as well informed as chuck :D.

I'm guessing that Curtis must have felt pressure to go to the trip edge from all the Fisher guys around here. Are they still going to use the trip blade? Also will the v be a trip blade? The only reason I know anything about these plows is that one of my subs runs an 8 footer and he loves it and I've seen more and more around here.

The curtis V plow is a full trip design. My friend switched the controls to the v plow for his truck, but with the lousy winter, and getting the prototype late in the season didn't get to use it. The v plow is very beefy. My friend told Mark Curtis (one of the owners) about some changes they should make for the v plow and they're using his changes for it. Curtis is still not that well known, but i think in a few more years they'll become more popular. For those considering a boss v plow, look into a curtis also.


Bryan:waving:
 

snow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
Connecticut
Ok, i put all the photos of the v plow into my webshots account. Here's the link photos

There's also some pics of the plow he made a mount for to go into his ford 4000 industrial loader, and his hough loader he just aquired.


Bryan
 
I have a Fisher and love the trip edge. Two big advantages that I see. One, when it trips you don't lose what your pushing, it stays on the moldboard. Two, I pushed snow for another contractor when he broke 4 of his 6 pickups in a very wet snow. Went to a mall and the pickups with foldovers couldn't get half a plow full without folding over. I just loades up and pushed like crazy. Trip edge is a definite advantage. As for gravel thats loose, use the shoes.
 

Top Forums

Similar threads

Similar threads

Top