Atf-?

slplow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
FRAMINGHAM, MA
A local fisher dealer told me to buy atf over the fisher hydro fluid for my insta-act. He told me fisher say's it's the same as their fluid. I think he is full of it. I have used it in my under hood belt drive's and under hood electric sys but not my out side electric
What do you guy's think? Have you ever used atf in your out side systems ?
 

NoStockBikes!!

Senior Member
Location
Minnesota
I was told to use "aircraft grade" hydraulic fluid, supposed to be good to 60 below. Plowing in -25 (or even worse) is NOT out of the question around here, so I was planning to either do that or find some synthetic ATF to make sure it stays fluid no matter what.
 

ProSno

Senior Member
Location
Walingford, Ct.
I have run atf in my fisher out front electric units since 1988 and never had a freeze up or any other problems. We also drain our units every year and replace old fluid.
 

Eager Beaver

Senior Member
I have used ATF on all my units and have never had a problem. Like someone said above just keep your fluid changed every year and I don't think it would be a good idea to mix the aircraft and the regular ATF together. May not hurt but I wouldn't want to replace a pump taking a chance.
 

WHITE=GREEN

Senior Member
john,
just curious what fluid youll be using in that new "fleet" of blizzard plows? im using regular ATF in mine. blizzard told me ATF would work fine just doesnt have the additives for real cold temps.
 

NoStockBikes!!

Senior Member
Location
Minnesota
My Western manual says to use :Wester High Performance to minus 25, ATF Dexron III to minus 10F, and Texaco 1537 Aircraft Hydraulic oil for below minus 25.

SO The aircraft stuff would not wreck your pump. If anything, having cold-gelled fluid would be bad for it, IMO.
 
OP
S

slplow

PlowSite.com Veteran
Location
FRAMINGHAM, MA
Just checked my manuals, fisher use only fisher hydraulic fluid. My boss says boss hydraulic or equivalaent and my 97 western says the same as fisher (western fluid)
So from the sounds of it, It's just a sales gimmic to sell their high price oil over atf.
 

Jerre Heyer

Senior Member
Location
Erie, PA
It's all in the service. Like the guys who change the fluid every year like they are suppose to. They are helping to insure trouble free equipment.

Just for fun try this test. Buy a quart of that expensive FIsher, Buy some meyers Blue, Grab a quart of Western(/ You already bought it - FIsher oil), Grab a quart of ATF... ......... Warn the wife or significant other if this next step will cause a problem

Put a pint of each in the Freezer and let sit for a few hours. Pull them out and place next to a pint of each at room temp. Stir each and see which one is thicker at both temps.

Or save yourself the trouble. Low temp fluid will perform much better. ALso there are anti-corrosion additives in most of them.


We do service on all types of pump. The ATF is cheap but the low temp oil causes less overall problems and the unit's last longer. Just my .02

Jerre
 

jakegypsum

Senior Member
Location
new jersey
I have been running ATF in the same Western pump since 1980. Also, ATF in the same Meyer pump since 82'. No problems at all and service has been missed from time to time. Not happy to mention that but bottom line. ATF hasn't let me down.
 

Pelican

2000 Club Member
I had used nothing but ATF since I started plowing, and never had oil related problems. Last season I switched to synthetic hydraulic fluid for the Blizzard, it doesn't congeal like ATF in sud zero weather. We only get those temps occasionally here, but being a former Boy Scout, "Be prepared" always sticks in my mind.
 

paul soccodato

Senior Member
Location
westchester ny
ive always run atf and never had any problems with it. just make sure the whole hydraulic system is clean, and you change the fluid anually. sometimes water can get in the system and wreak havoc.
 

NoStockBikes!!

Senior Member
Location
Minnesota
Well, I ended up going with the best of both worlds, should make everybody happy: Synthetic ATF (Dexron III). Amsoil ATF, good to minus 72 degrees F. :D I was gonna do the aircraft grade hydraulic, but I went to Napa and they didn't have that, but they had synthetic ATF. I have a 'preferred customer' membership thing, but didn't want to mess aroudn with placing an order that small, and I needed to get the plow out of my garage ASAP. SO, I forked over $7/qt jsut for the convenience of it. Thank god those pumps are nice and small, eh? They had Valvoline semi-synthetic cheaper, but I didn't see a temp rating on it.
 

jakegypsum

Senior Member
Location
new jersey
Sounds like you made a good choice! Any extra that you may pay is no biggie. It's better than being let down in the middle of a snow storm!:realmad: :D Good luck. Jake.
 

Top Forums

Similar threads

Similar threads

Top