1. Welcome to PlowSite. Notice a fresh look and new features? It’s now easier to share photos and videos, find popular topics fast, and enjoy expanded user profiles. If you have any questions, click HELP at the top or bottom of any page, or send an email to help@plowsite.com. We welcome your feedback.

    Dismiss Notice

Hiniker vs Western

Discussion in 'Commercial Snow Removal' started by orange toys, Jan 5, 2010.

  1. orange toys

    orange toys Member
    Messages: 76

    My dealers has both brands but says everyone in the area is wanting the hinikers, but from the reading i have done the western is the way to go. What do you all think is the better plow and why?
  2. sno commander

    sno commander PlowSite.com Addict
    from ct
    Messages: 1,061

    id go with the western, there well built, easy to hook up and part support is good
  3. niederhauser la

    niederhauser la Member
    from Utah
    Messages: 79

    Just look at them side by side. The western is build so much better!
  4. exmark1

    exmark1 PlowSite.com Addict
    Messages: 1,320

    I have had Hiniker V-Plows for years now...My new truck I am getting this week will be getting a MVP Western. I have been happy overall with the Hinikers, but am looking to try something different and the dealer has really good pricing on them right now!
  5. toptech72

    toptech72 Member
    from 21078
    Messages: 61

    We have 2 Hiniker V plows and have had no issues with them. The western we have (straight blade) has been nothing but trouble.
  6. MileHigh

    MileHigh PlowSite.com Addict
    Messages: 1,827

    My buddies got 4 westerns...all with problems.

    Personally I like plows that have Direct Lift as opposed to the Chain Lift....That is the deciding factor for myself...So I choose Hiniker.
  7. ondirtymax

    ondirtymax Member
    Messages: 70

    The only thing that scares me about direct lift is if the plow won't lift your euchared! At least with a chain lift you can short chain the blade to get back to the shop.
  8. MileHigh

    MileHigh PlowSite.com Addict
    Messages: 1,827

    Ok lets see...How would you short chain a direct lift plow? The same way you would a chainer...only without a chain.

    You would drive into a pile (or jack plow up) and use a ratchet strap to "short chain" the direct lift plow.
  9. ondirtymax

    ondirtymax Member
    Messages: 70

    only with a chainer you would just shorten the chain, no need for a ratchet strap, but yes point taken. I was not being smart assed, I have never used a direct lift blade and do not know how the system works, or if it could be "short chained"...........now i know, thx for the info:salute:
  10. Rossland&seal

    Rossland&seal Junior Member
    Messages: 5

    Hiniker push-plates

    We have a 3 year old Hiniker c-plow, and the push plates have completely severed 2 out of the last 3 years, with the plow falling off of the truck. I also know of 2 other contractors in our area that have had the same problems {and only a few companys have hinikers in our area}. We have also have had problems with the motor and solenoids in the past. Now all we run are Fisher v plows and Fisher XLS plows and we have yet to have a problem.
  11. ondirtymax

    ondirtymax Member
    Messages: 70

    What do you mean by push plates? As in the mold boards?
  12. Rossland&seal

    Rossland&seal Junior Member
    Messages: 5


    yes, the actual frame on the truck, we actually broke our second set 2 days ago, we are getting a set of forks custom fabricated this week
  13. jake2333

    jake2333 Junior Member
    Messages: 13


    I have ran Hininker plows for 5 years and have had zero problems until this year. I too had the fork bust right off the truck. I have heard some others have this and Hiniker ignores the flaw. I have been completely satisfied otherwise....hope that does not happen again.
  14. Rossland&seal

    Rossland&seal Junior Member
    Messages: 5


    Our truck with the hiniker c plow is going up for sale it has been nothing but problems. when it works it pull plows and scrapes good but there is too much down time due to break downs. we replaced it with a fisher xls 8"-10" ft. expanding plow. We do a lot of condos with a lot of pull plowing and the xls backdrags just as good as the c plow pull plows.
  15. orange toys

    orange toys Member
    Messages: 76

    besides the hiniker c plow having some motor/solinoid issues how is the plow its self when working correctly
  16. Cooter24

    Cooter24 Senior Member
    from NE Iowa
    Messages: 268

    I have an older C-plow and it has given me no troubles whatsoever. They will all break at some point. Hopefully you can catch it while still minor. I would recommend the Hiniker.
  17. Pushin 2 Please

    Pushin 2 Please PlowSite Veteran
    Messages: 4,559

    Yeah that sounds good! Hooking up a ratchet strap at 4 in the morning in the cold. I have a direct lift with my Boss and love it. ITS DEPENDABLE. I've had Hiniker and like the others said it was nothing but problems. The plow doesn't go high enough in IMO, even after adjusting the "horns". The truck side "horns" are a horrible design, they start to bend down after a few years. Western all the way and you if want the direct lift Boss. Stay away Fromm Hiniker!
  18. ABES

    ABES PlowSite.com Addict
    from MN
    Messages: 1,322

    I purchased a Western this past fall and havent had any issues with it yet (knock on wood), although it is an older unimount I have been hearing about quality issues with the new Westerns. There is 2 major problems I have with the hinikers 1) the grill plugs are too small and corode easily and are very hard to get a good connection. 2) the truck mounting forks are weak and break off right at the notch letting the plow fall off of the truck:mad:
  19. orange toys

    orange toys Member
    Messages: 76

    in my area i bet you see 5 hinikers to 1 of any other brand.
  20. MileHigh

    MileHigh PlowSite.com Addict
    Messages: 1,827

    I was simply referring too how to transport a broken direct lift plow....

    One question smart guy...

    How would you "short chain" your direct lift boss plow at 4 in the morning in the cold????

    My lord.